FSP and Silverstone PSU Compared in Crossfire Stress Test

Cases & PSU/Power Supplies by geoffrey @ 2007-07-27

We take a look at two high wattage power supplies from companies known for their solid product lines; the Silverstone DA750 model features a single 12v rail and is rated at 750W. The FSP Epsilon has four 12v rails and combined offers up to 900W. We stress test these units in a real world environment with the most power hungry vga cards out there, two ATI HD 2900 XT in Crossfire. Read on to find out if they pass our tests

  • prev
  • next

Specifications compared

Specifications compared


Comparing the specifications of both products reveals their design differences; the Silverstone is a single rail 12V unit, while the FSP adheres to the Intel specifications and split the 12V into different rails. Each design has its advantages, our practical tests will show if they translate into a real life difference.


In the table below we compare the different voltage rails and their maximum output as well as the extra security features:



Silverstone DA750
FSP Epsilon 900
Input voltage
110 ~ 240 Vac
110 ~ 240 Vac
Input frequency
50 - 60 Hz
50 - 60 Hz
PFC
Active
Active
Maximum DC output
750W
900W
Over-Current Protection
Yes
Yes
Over-Voltage Protection
Yes
Yes
Short Circuit Protection
Yes
Yes
Maximum +3,3V current
28A
30A
Maximum +5V current
30A
30A
Maximum +12V current

60A

4 x 20A (max 70A)

Combined +3V, +5V output
180W
175W
Combined +12V output
720W
700W


At first sight one would think that FSP's Epsilon has a lot more power headroom than the Silverstone's PSU, there is a 150W difference in rating, though once you start looking more closely at the specifications you'll notice that both PSU's are in fact very on par.

Silverstone DA750 combined power offered at the 3,3V and 5V levels even surpasses that of the FSP Epsilon, the same goes for the its +12V, quite impressive for a single 12V rail PSU.

We can find the same kind of protection circuit's inside and both PSU's also come with active PFC. Strictly on paper; it’s already a hard decision between the two. Let’s look at the connectors:

Silverstone DA750
FSP Epsilon 900
20 + 4 pins ATX connector
1
1
8 pins EPS12V connector
1
2 x 4 pins
4 pins ATX12V connector
1
1
8 pins PCIe 2.0 connector
1
0
6 pins PCIe connector
2 x 2 connectors
2 x 2 connectors
SATA connector
6
8
4 pins molex connector
6
6
4 pins floppy connector
1
1
Color
Black
Blue
Cooling

120 mm fan

120 mm fan

Dimensions (LxWxH)

150*180*86 (mm)

140*150*86(mm)



Both PSU's have a high availability of different connectors, this is important for high-end PSU's as users probable do not want to run CrossFire/SLI alone with one single hard disk drive, instead it could be quite possible to find 4 HDD's or more together with a couple of optic devices inside their housings. Silverstone’s DA750 can supply up to 6 SATA devices where FSP's Epsilon can even provide power for another 2 devices more. On the other hand we couldn't find any 8-pin PCIe connector on the Epsilon, but for now the 6-pin PCIe do just fine, even in CrossFire.

Madshrimps (c)


Silverstone and FSP have thought about compatibility with large computer housing, the shortest cable connector is still more then 50 cm away from the PSU itself. The molex and SATA connectors reach even further and will cause no problems in even the largest pc housing where the PSU might be sitting at the bottom and a SATA DVD drive near the very top of the case.

Stress testing will give us the best idea of what those PSU are capable of ->
  • prev
  • next
Comment from MTBF @ 2010/03/10
FORTRON / FSP Power Supply Units are unreliable hardware devices.
Failed just after 784 days of normal use (about 3500 hours only)!.
Comment from jmke @ 2010/03/10
MTBF doesn't guarantee you a minimum life-time expectancy FYI
Comment from MTBF @ 2010/03/10
Yes, 2 years but warranty was over since 1,5 month only.
Comment from jmke @ 2010/03/10
how many FSP PSU do you own?
Comment from MTBF @ 2010/03/10
Just one, Epsilon 700w definitively useless by now also it was properly protected with an UPS.
Such material is normally designed for 100,000 hours.
Comment from jmke @ 2010/03/10
Quote:
Such material is normally designed for 100,000 hours.
no, it has MTBF of 100.000 hours. And MTBF != LifeTime

Quote:
nother common misconception about the MTBF is that it specifies the time (on average) when the probability of failure equals the probability of not having a failure (i.e. a reliability of 50%). This is only true for certain symmetric distributions. In many cases, such as the (non-symmetric) exponential distribution, this is not the case. In particular, for an exponential failure distribution, the probability that an item will fail at or before the MTBF is approximately 0.63 (i.e. the reliability at the MTBF is 37%). For typical distributions with some variance, MTBF only represents a top-level aggregate statistic, and thus is not suitable for predicting specific time to failure, the uncertainty arising from the variability in the time-to-failure distribution.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mean_ti...sconcepti ons
you can't decide on experience with ONE sample that a whole range of products is broken/bad.
Comment from MTBF @ 2010/03/10
I agree with you and the above MTBF but when you pay US$200 for a device you don't expect that you should do it again 2 years later... :-)
Especially when the breakdown is obviously the device itself.
Comment from jmke @ 2010/03/10
I've had laptops break down a week after their warranty has expired, sometimes you get the short end of the stick
the other 200 laptops kept working years after their warranty expired.... that's life
Comment from EsaT @ 2010/03/24
Quote:
Originally Posted by jmke View Post
you can't decide on experience with ONE sample that a whole range of products is broken/bad.
Epsilon platform based PSUs commonly show "ripple happiness" from the start (even some advertised PSU specs breaking ATX specification) and FSP uses mostly cheap capacitors avoided by many makers.
So with such product propability of getting that short end of the stick is simply higher.
Comment from ToyTen @ 2010/04/01
I am a lucky owner of an 800w Epsilon PSU then. Since the Geforce 8800GTX and I used those in SLI with a Q600 for more than one year. My PSU is still there.
Not saying at all that problems never occur of course, but it seemed to me that a positive feedback about those PSU's was welcome here, supplying a 5870 and an I7 950 @ 3200Mhz with 4Ghz UCLK, 3 HDD and 6Gigs of memory. Also lots of fan for my water cooling.

 

reply